Fleet News

Speed cameras 'aren't working', says leasing company

Huge numbers of drivers are avoiding speeding penalties through by slowing down for cameras and speeding up again once they are out of range, says a car leasing company.

"Over 50,000 drivers receive a court summons every year for speeding," said Flexed.co.uk 's Mark Hall, "but for every conviction, there's scores who escape the law."

Flexed.co.uk spoke to almost 3,000 drivers about their driving habits, and found that many used simple tricks to avoid detection.

They included: slowing down when approaching a known a speed camera site, then speeding up again – a trick used by 80% of all drivers; using a sat nav that features fixed speed camera sites – 15%; and illegal coatings on number plates to avoid being photographed – 1%.

A survey earlier this year revealed that more than two-thirds of drivers admitted to habitual speeding, particularly on their way to work when roads are at their busiest.

"It just goes to show that drivers think they can avoid speeding fines if they're smart enough," said Hall, "But speeding's not smart – it kills."

With manned mobile camera units responsible for up to a quarter of speed camera penalties, Flexed thinks there should be more emphasis on their use rather than the far more common fixed site automated cameras which many savvy local drivers have wised up to over the years.

"It's clear that the 'surprise' element of the mobile camera works very well and modifies driver behaviour in areas where they operate. They show the fixed cameras for the inefficient system and lazy cash cow that they are," said Hall.

"Everybody knows where their local cameras are, and they're only effective for about 100 yards."

Flexed thinks that better systems should be in place to educate drivers and modify behaviour to hammer down speeding and slash the number of road deaths on British roads.

Among schemes backed by the car leasing company are:

• Greater use of mobile speed cameras instead of fixed-site cameras

• More deterrent fines, especially for offences in 20mph and 30mph zones

• Making the speed awareness course compulsory for all convicted of speeding, and make an adapted version a compulsory part of new driver training

• Consideration of average speed cameras – studies find 99% compliance, even when dummy cameras are deployed

"Despite years of ham-fisted attempts to get drivers to slow down, the lessons aren't being learned," says Hall. "The motivation for police authorities should be effectiveness, not raising money through cameras.

"We firmly believe education in partnership with targeted punishment is the best way forward."
 


Click here for safety and risk management best practice and procurement insight

Leave a comment for your chance to win £20 of John Lewis vouchers.

Every issue of Fleet News the editor picks his favourite comment from the past two weeks – get involved for your chance to appear in print and win!

Login to comment

Comments

  • Bob the Engineer - 23/09/2014 09:47

    I can see why a leasing company would want more speeding convictions, its a nice little earner! lease companies add on disproportionately large 'admin' charges onto drivers for passing on speeding fines. A good profit margin to be made from a couple of photocopies and a stamp. The sensible discussion here is are speed limits realistically set for model vehicles? (outside the SE of England at least where any motion at all seems fast)

  • Ralph - 24/09/2014 03:37

    We are told that fixed cameras are positioned in locations of potential danger, usually as a result of past incidents, and often it is suggested these have resulted in fatalities. If cars slow down when they are entering and passing through this high risk zone, then the camera has done its job even if cars speed up afterwards. It isn't the most ideal situation but it clearly works if it causes the majority of drivers to reduce their speed in the "Accident Black Spot". I can sort of see the point that Bob is making but ultimately a driver who receives multiple convictions ultimately risks being banned and would therefore cease to be a "customer". Speed limits are a maximum and while I try to stay within the law as much as possible, during the day there are some occasions when even 20mph in a 30mph zone is too fast if it is near a school during term time.

Compare costs of your company cars

Looking to acquire new vehicles? Check how much they'll cost to run with our Car Running Cost calculator.

What is your BIK car tax liability?

The Fleet News car tax calculator lets you work out tax costs for both employer and employee