Fleet News

Diesel remains the 'only realistic' fuel type for fleets

Fuel pumps, petrol station pumps.

Diesel fuel is the only realistic choice for business-critical and high-mileage fleets, according to analysis by Pendragon Vehicle Management (PVM).

It has been a longstanding choice of fuel for UK vehicle fleets due to its exceptional fuel economy but it has come under the spotlight recently as a cause for poor air quality. This has seen some areas propose bans or additional fees to vehicles that run on this fuel type.

After analysing a typical 270-strong fleet of diesel vehicles in the construction industry against electric vehicles (EV) and plug-in hybrid electric vehicles (PHEV), PVM found that it would cost 8.5% more per annum to run a PHEV fleet than a diesel one, equating to an additional spend of £280,000 over two years. This is due to higher P11D values and the monthly rental costs, which counteract the BIK and NIC savings.

Neal Francis, divisional managing director for Pendragon Vehicle Management, said: “In recent weeks and months various press headlines have prematurely portrayed diesel vehicles in a poor light.

“Aged and poorly maintained diesel vehicles are very harmful to the environment. However, for those who change their vehicles typically every 4 years, the new diesel technology and emission standards are class-leading with the economic and environmental argument compelling.”

For workhorse fleets, EVs and PHEVs will not be the ideal choice for most, due to the high costs and limited ranges they can travel before requiring a lengthy charge. Diesel provides reliability, cost-effectiveness and can keep the vehicle moving for longer, which is a huge advantage to fleet customers.                     

Click here for fuel and fuel cards best practice and procurement insight

Leave a comment for your chance to win £20 of John Lewis vouchers.

Every issue of Fleet News the editor picks his favourite comment from the past two weeks – get involved for your chance to appear in print and win!

Comment as guest

Login  /  Register


  • Robberg - 22/06/2017 11:23

    Based on this and other information I've seen, I can’t see why EU6 diesel is under threat at all. Compared to petrol they have lower CO2’s with almost identical NOX and much better MPG. But when did the facts ever change anything when the mass media seem to want to demonise all diesels?

    Reply as guest

    Login  /  Register
  • Glenn Ewen - 27/06/2017 22:39

    Currently, diesel is cheaper. But what happens if, in an attempt to clean the air up in urban areas, the Government begin to penalise diesel vehicles with RFL, fuel duty and tax disincentives? Then all bets are off. We've known about dirty diesel for years. Saying things will not change is not the answer. Things must change. Time to get inventive and not just spout about electric. There are other alternatives that have been around for years: LPG, CNG spring to mind. Can diesels not be converted to run on petrol? Maybe that could be tried by manufacturers instead of scrappage?

    Reply as guest

    Login  /  Register