Fleet News

Renault Laguna Coupe DCi 180 GT (2009)

Renault

Review

3

It’s very rare to get into a car and for it to feel alien. Most models conform to a set of parameters in terms of ride and handling, but in the case of the new Renault Laguna Coupé you really do feel somehow out of sorts for the first few miles.

The reason is the very clever 4Control chassis fitted to GT specification Laguna Coupés such as the one on test.

Essentially, it is a four-wheel steer system which allows the rear wheels to either turn in the opposite direction to the fronts to aid low-speed manouevring, or mirror the action of the fronts at higher speeds to make the car more stable.

And it all works brilliantly, once you get used to its feel. At low speeds, and especially when trying to move around a tight car parking space, the effort needed from the driver is much reduced.

But I was caught out several times when circulating a roundabout – I simply put too much lock on the wheel to go round and was then forced to take some off as it became clear I was heading for the kerb in the middle.

Such directness is uncommon in modern day vehicles – the last car I drove that turned-in so quickly was a Ford Racing Puma.
The 4Control system makes the Laguna Coupé a great car to drive – secure, direct, comfortable and, above all, safe.

There’s a range of engines to add to the enjoyment, and our test car is fitted with the 2.0-litre diesel offering 180bhp. 

Again, it’s good news because this engine is a peach. Little in the way of lag, smooth power delivery, low noise intrusion and huge puddles of torque available for effortless acceleration.

The six-speed manual gearbox fitted feels a little baggy in its action, but this fails to spoil what is a very accomplished car.

And then there’s the looks. Some sections of the media have panned Renault for its styling of the Laguna, especially at the front-end. I don’t find this look anywhere near as offensive as some of my colleagues, and for the Coupé it is little changed in overall appearance.

The big difference comes at the back, where a pair of thin light strips and a little ducktail spoiler dominate. There’s a definite trace of Aston Martin to the look, and the tight design gives it an air of sophisticated simplicity.

The Laguna Coupé is also very well equipped in GT trim, with full leather interior, cruise and climate control, Bluetooth telephony, automatic lights and wipers and bi-xenon headlights as standard equipment.

The Laguna’s pricing sees it sit plum between the volume and premium marques, so will the looks and kit be enough to tempt user-choosers? Read on...

 

Three rivals to consider

  • Audi A5 2.0 TDI
  • BMW 320d SE Coupé
  • Peugeot 407 Coupé HDi Sport M/media
     

P11D price

The Peugeot is the cheapest and comes well equipped, but it offers 136bhp compared with between 170 and 180bhp for the others.

The Audi and BMW are in entry-level trim while the Renault comes loaded with kit – leather, cruise control, 18-inch alloys and Bluetooth.

  • 407 £22,017
  • Laguna £24,120
  • A5 £27,710
  • 320d £27,790
     

Emissions and tax rates

The Peugeot is the cheapest in BIK tax, costing a 40% taxpayer £161 a month, compared with £167 a month for the BMW.

The Audi will cost the same taxpayer £175 a month, while the Renault lags well behind and will cost £201 a month in BIK tax.

  • 320d 128g/km/18%
  • A5 140g/km/19%
  • 407 156g/km/22%
  • Laguna 172g/km/25%
     

SMR cost

With 18-inch alloy wheels, the Renault will have the most expensive tyre costs (the other three run on 17-inch wheels), and its fixed 18,000-mile service intervals are the shortest of the group.

The 407 will need attention every 20,000 miles while the Audi and BMW come with variable servicing intervals.

ppm/60k total
 

  • 320d 3.91/£2,346
  • 407 4.01/£2,406
  • A5 4.38/£2,628
  • Laguna 4.80/£2,880


Fuel cost

With claimed combined fuel economy of 58.9mpg, the BMW leads the way and will cost just under £5,000 in diesel over 60,000 miles.

The Audi is second on 53.3mpg while the others fail to break the 50mpg mark (48mpg for the 407 and 43.4 for the Renault).

  • 320d 8.27/£4,962
  • A5 8.94/£5,364
  • 407 9.93/£5,958
  • Laguna 10.99/£6,594
     

Depreciation cost

The Audi retains the most value after three years and 60,000 miles, with CAP estimating it will be worth £11,700 (41% of cost new).

The BMW is next on £9,575 (34%). The French duo have low RVs – the Renault worth £6,925 (29%) and the 407 just £5,575 (25%).

  • A5 26.26/£15,756
  • 407 27.23/£16,338
  • Laguna 28.45/£17,070
  • 320d 29.98/£17,988
     

Wholelife cost

The highest fuel and SMR costs, plus the worst depreciation, confine the Laguna to last place – it seems Renault’s positioning of the car and the guides’ RV predictions are not in the same area.

The Audi will be the cheapest to run, and is the only car to drop below the 40ppm barrier.

  • A5 39.58/£23,748
  • 407 41.17/£24,702
  • 320d 42.16/£25,296
  • Laguna 44.24/£26,544
     

Verdict

Choosing a coupé involves far more emotion than the selection process for a saloon or hatchback, and as such the Laguna makes a strong emotive case for itself. It looks right, is well equipped and drives very well.

Unfortunately, a degree of cold, hard logic needs to enter the equation, and the fact that the Laguna is the most expensive to run and costs a driver the most in BIK tax confines it to last place.

The Peugeot is also discounted – its styling lacks cohesion and it cannot compete on power and driving terms with the rivals here. So, predictably enough, the winner will be German and it is the Audi’s running costs advantage which seals victory from the BMW.

  • WINNER: Audi A5 2.0 TDI

CO2 emissions and fuel consumption data correct at time of writing. The latest figures are available in the Fleet News fuel cost calculator and the company car tax calculator.

Renault Clio E-Tech first drive | new hybrid is a better fleet choice

The addition of a hybrid powertrain has made the Clio an even more convincing fleet offering.

Road test: Audi TT Coupe 2.0 S line TDI Ultra 184 6 speed car review

Third generation surprisingly popular sporty choice for fleets

Search Car Reviews

Leave a comment for your chance to win £20 of John Lewis vouchers.

Every issue of Fleet News the editor picks his favourite comment from the past two weeks – get involved for your chance to appear in print and win!

Comment as guest


Login  /  Register

Comments

No comments have been made yet.