Fleet News

Guest opinion: End of the road in sight for free ride

DON’T you just hate people who don’t pay their fair share – whether it’s the guy who always hangs back in the pub when it comes to his round, the person who thinks it clever not to pay his proper taxes or the truck operator who pays not a penny towards the upkeep of our roads.

It’s this last category I want to sound off about – the truck driver who lands at Dover, or who comes through the Channel Tunnel on Le Shuttle, with a tank brim full of diesel holding 400 or more litres. I say a tank but often it’s two, each at 400 litres.

That gives him a range of more than 1,500 miles – enough easily for a trip to Scotland and out again – all without paying a penny to the UK. In fuel duty he’s saved a packet. Diesel duty in the UK is 47.1 pence per litre while across the rest of the EU it’s 22ppl. On 800 litres that’s a saving of £200 a trip. The problem with simple ideas is that often they are complex when put into practice. But this one can be done simply. Using standardised, and I emphasise the standardised, black box technology, each truck will have the distance it has travelled recorded and a bill will be sent to the operator. The operator pays the bill and reclaims against his fuel receipts. Simple. Trucks from overseas will have no fuel receipts to offset their LRUC bills and will thus contribute to the UK road infrastructure.

But tax neutrality is a hard objective to achieve. The calculations to arrive at such a position are impossibly difficult so the Government can only put forward its best estimate. But of course, the charge can be varied to take account of time of day, roads used and prevailing congestion and it is on this last point that I have most concern.

The Department for Transport may well become involved and use the LRUC as a means of attempting to reduce congestion by flexing the charge. So, perhaps the cheapest rate would be on the M8 in Scotland at 3am but herein lies a further problem – the lack of joined-up government. Most local authorities ban deliveries to shops, for example, between 11pm and 7am, so trucks would not be able to take advantage of the low charge rates. Do you see now what I mean about the tax neutrality calculations being impossibly difficult?

The LRUC will come into force and of course, we have reservations about how rental companies will be able to manage the allocation of charges among their customers. But we are working with HM Customs, who will collect the charge, and we are confident of an eventual and successful outcome.

But if trucks will be charged for road use from 2007/8, when will cars be brought into a similar regime? Our support for the LRUC does not, of course, automatically extend to other road user charging schemes some of which are blatant revenue raisers. The Chancellor already takes more than £40 billion from the motorist each year and pays back less than £10 billion in infrastructure improvements. He will take billions more in a car road user charge.

It’s up to each one of us to make sure that this additional money is spent on transport infrastructure and not on general expenditure. We need better roads with less congestion and integrated public transport systems – for these are the arteries through which our nation’s economy flows. Without such improvements how can we hope to remain competitive in the longer term?

John Lewis
Director-general, British Vehicle Rental and Leasing Association

Leave a comment for your chance to win £20 of John Lewis vouchers.

Every issue of Fleet News the editor picks his favourite comment from the past two weeks – get involved for your chance to appear in print and win!

Login to comment


No comments have been made yet.

Compare costs of your company cars

Looking to acquire new vehicles? Check how much they'll cost to run with our Car Running Cost calculator.

What is your BIK car tax liability?

The Fleet News car tax calculator lets you work out tax costs for both employer and employee