Fleet News

Auris score highly in crash tests - two other vehicles 'appalling'

TOYOTA'S Corolla replacement, the new Auris, has achieved a five star rating for adult occupant protection from Euro NCAP.

But two other vehicles in the latest round of tests have peformed appallingly, according to Euro NCAP.

Standard fit ISOFIX anchorage points on the outer rear seats of the Auris helped gain a four-star rating for child occupant protection. Euro NCAP also awarded the Auris a three-star rating for pedestrian protection.

The detailed Euro NCAP results show that the Toyota Auris scored 35 points for passenger protection (maximum: 37 points), 37 points for child protection (max: 48 points) and 21 points for pedestrian protection (max. 27).

The Auris is on sale in the UK from February 1.

Other cars tested were the Hyundai Santa Fe, Kia Magentis and Skoda Roomster. The Roomster, was awarded a five star rating for adult occupant protection. The Magentis and the Sante Fe are both awarded four stars.

Despite the Skoda’s excellent five star adult occupant rating, Euro NCAP’s tests identified a weakness in the Roomster. Main battery power cables are vulnerable to damage as they are routed down the front of the battery.

In the frontal crash test, these cables were damaged resulting in a loss of electrical power. As a consequence, the seat belt pretensioners failed to fire.

Skoda proposed the fitment of reinforced sleeves over the cables to protect the cables. They also proposed a modification that maintained sufficient electrical supply to fire the pretensioners, even if the cables were damaged.

In a retest, the cable protection was found to be inadequate with some cables again being damaged. However, the other modifications did ensure that the seat belt pretensioners operated correctly.

Euro NCAP asked if Skoda planned to modify cars already sold but was disappointed to learn that there are no plans to do this. Skoda has applied the modifications to vehicles from VIN number TMBVCB5J875025783.

The Hyundai Santa Fe is given a zero-star rating for its pedestrian protection after failing to score a single point. The Kia Magentis also does 'extremely badly', scoring only three points for a one-star rating.

Tingvall said: 'These are appalling results from these two Korean manufacturers. It has taken the car industry a long time to address the issue of pedestrian safety but several manufacturers are now making improvements and the Toyota Auris joins a growing list of three star cars. For the Santa Fe not to score a single point shows that Hyundai have made no effort whatever to protect pedestrians and reflects a worrying disregard for the safety of this important group of road-users. Manufacturers like Hyundai and Kia are now a long way behind the front-runners and it is high time that they realise that such poor results are unacceptable.'

  • In another development, SEAT has reversed it decision to remove the seatbelt reminder system from the Leon.

    Euro NCAP was told that the safety feature would be axed at the end of August 2006, as part of a cost-saving exercise and asked Seat to reconsider this decision. After receiving no response, Euro NCAP issued a press release in August informing consumers of SEAT’s proposed action.

    SEAT has now told Euro NCAP they have no plans to remove the seat belt reminder from the Leon.

    Tingvall said: "This shows the influence that public opinion can have on car manufacturers when it comes to maintaining the highest levels of safety. We are pleased that SEAT have responded as they have."

    Summary of results

    Small family car

  • Toyota Auris
    Occupant protection: 5 stars
    Child protection: 4 stars
    Pedestrian protection: 3 stars

    Large family

  • Kia Magentis
    Occupant protection: 4 stars
    Child protection: 3 stars
    Pedestrian protection: 1 stars

    Small MPV

  • Skoda Roomster Occupant protection: 5 stars
    Child protection: 4 stars
    Pedestrian protection: 2 stars

    Large off-roader

  • Hyundai Santa Fe
    Occupant protection: 4 stars
    Child protection: 4 stars
    Pedestrian protection: 0 stars
  • Leave a comment for your chance to win £20 of John Lewis vouchers.

    Every issue of Fleet News the editor picks his favourite comment from the past two weeks – get involved for your chance to appear in print and win!

    Login to comment


    No comments have been made yet.

    Compare costs of your company cars

    Looking to acquire new vehicles? Check how much they'll cost to run with our Car Running Cost calculator.

    What is your BIK car tax liability?

    The Fleet News car tax calculator lets you work out tax costs for both employer and employee