Fleet News

MOT must stay annual argues RoadSafe

RoadSafe is urging transport minister Mike Penning, to maintain the MOT test as an annual check up for vehicles.

In 2008, the Department for Transport said the MOT failure rate was high, at 35%. Between 2009 and 10, the failure rate continued its steady increase to 37%.   Despite this, the DfT is looking into reducing the required frequency of tests to fall in line with Europe.

In the UK, vehicles must have their first test within three years of registration, and annual tests thereafter. As a minimum, EU law requires vehicles to have their first test when they are four years old and subsequent tests every two years.

Most European countries follow the EU minimum requirement and there is pressure on the UK to do the same. RoadSafe is warning that this will lead to more crashes, caused by poorly maintained vehicles.

Testers in the UK identify 8.5 million cars with defects every year. In its own review of the MOT in 2008, the DfT said reducing the test’s frequency would significantly increase the number of unroadworthy cars and casualties. 

Vehicle owners are expected to service their vehicles between tests, but there is evidence that many drivers fail to. The Tyre Industry Federation says 12% of tyres are illegal on replacement, and this number is increasing as the economic downturn continues.

RoadSafe director, Adrian Walsh says, “Many owners just don’t realise that tyres are a vital part of the braking system. They are one of several essential safety features that drivers seldom check.

“An annual MOT is vital for picking up these problems. RoadSafe joins the Tyre Industry Federation, and other campaigners, with a warning to government, that extending the period between MOT tests will put lives at risk.”

One argument for increasing the time before a vehicle’s first MOT and reducing the frequency of subsequent tests, is that modern vehicles are more reliable. RoadSafe shares the view that newer vehicles are usually more dependable, but warns that this is a separate issue from the MOT.

The responsibility for a vehicle’s roadworthiness lies with the owner. No matter how well a vehicle is made, if the owner fails to take appropriate care of it, it will become unsafe.

Commercial vehicles can do up to 300,000 miles in their first three years on the road. In this time, they see significant wear, which can lead to higher failure rates for some vehicle groups. Class seven vans, for example, reportedly had a 50% failure rate in 2009/10.

RoadSafe argues that extending the time before a vehicle’s first MOT could increase the number of unsafe vehicles on our roads, which, as the DfT said itself in 2008, could lead to more road casualties.

RoadSafe urges government to keep the MOT test frequency as it is.

Click here for safety and risk management best practice and procurement insight

Leave a comment for your chance to win £20 of John Lewis vouchers.

Every issue of Fleet News the editor picks his favourite comment from the past two weeks – get involved for your chance to appear in print and win!

Login to comment


  • Richardtechnik - 31/08/2010 12:14

    So how many collisions on UK roads are principally caused by defective vehicles ? And who precisely are Roadsafe and whom do they represent ?

  • george.radanov@tgb.toyota.co.uk - 31/08/2010 14:18

    Whilst the safety aspect has to be taken into consideration surely a thought must go to the many garages out there who rely on ticking over by doing MOT work especially in this climate.

  • Bianca Castafiore - 31/08/2010 14:31

    I agree with the comments made by Richardtechnik (especially with regard to who actually are Roadsafe!). However, I believe the 12 months test is effective, particularly in view of many people being under the illusion that the MOT also doubles up as their yearly maintenance inspection. Take this away and the roadworthiness of cars on the roads, particularly those in the 5-10 year old bracket, will suffer. In turn, the insurance companies will then use this as their excuse to hike up their prices even more....

Compare costs of your company cars

Looking to acquire new vehicles? Check how much they'll cost to run with our Car Running Cost calculator.

What is your BIK car tax liability?

The Fleet News car tax calculator lets you work out tax costs for both employer and employee