One in five cars registered in 2010 failed its first MOT test, according to new Vehicle Operator and Services Agency (VOSA) data, analysed by TootCompare. 

Between January 1 and August 9 2013, 253,000 cars failed their MOT test when presented for the first time after being registered new.

Some 70 million MOT records from the VOSA were obtained and analysed by TootCompare.

Douglas Rotberg, CEO of TootCompare said: “As expected, Japanese and German manufacturers dominate the top of the manufacturers' table. Land Rover is a creditable exception to this rule, achieving an overall 84.3% pass rate. At the lower end of the manufacturers' table, we mostly see European manufacturers.

“The top models are again mainly Japanese, with a surprising number of compact SUVs in the top 10 - the Honda CR-V (89.8%), Lexus RX (89.3%) and Audi Q5 (89.3%). The Honda Jazz catches the eye as a high-volume model with a good pass rate of 90.4%, while Land Rover make it in to the table with the Freelander at 88.9%.

“At the bottom of the pass rate table, there are more likely to be models with above-average mileage for a 3-year old car - the Renault Kangoo (63.5%) and Citroen Berlingo (67.8%) for example, both typically being tested with over 40,000 miles on the clock. These are clearly hard working vehicles. But the Citroen C4 is a surprise, achieving a pass rate of only 67.9% on an average mileage at test of 23,600 miles.”

Below are the tables for the top ten best and worst makes and models.