Fleet News

Transport Manager’s Acquired Rights certificate removed

A transport manager who incorrectly applied for an Acquired Rights certificate has been told he can no longer rely on it.

Traffic Commissioner for the East of England, Richard Turfitt, took action to prevent Peter Dobney from relying on Acquired Rights after finding that he did not meet the criteria.

Removing his professional competence, the industry regulator said that Dobney would have to obtain a certificate of professional competence by examination before he could apply to be a transport manager again.

Dobney, who previously worked under Grandfather Rights, had failed to read guidance when he applied for the Acquired Rights certificate.

Applicants were required to have continuously managed a road haulage or road passenger transport  operation in a member state for a period of ten years before 04 December 2009.

At  a public inquiry into Hanby Farms Ltd, the licence on which Dobney was nominated transport manager, the Traffic Commissioner heard that he had not  realised  what  was required to meet  Article 9 of EC Regulations 1071/2009.

The firm was called before the Traffic Commissioner following a maintenance investigation by the Driver and Vehicle Standards Agency (DVSA) in March 2014.

A  vehicle examiner reported that the business had no vehicle safety inspection records, routine inspections had not been planned in advance and no driver defect reporting system was in place.  The business had also failed to notify the Commissioner of a change in maintenance provider, as required.

A  vehicle operated under the licence had also been issued with a prohibition for a brake related defect.

Operators are required to specify how frequently routine safety inspections will be undertaken on their fleet and ensure they happen on time.

During the inspection, Dobney was not available to assist the examiner.

He  asked a driver to provide paperwork to the DVSA officer but the documents did not give an accurate record of time between planned safety inspections.

After  hearing  evidence  from  the  business, Turfitt made an order to revoke the operator’s licence from 23:59 on 02 September. The order against Dobney  also  led  to  an  automatic  disqualification from acting as a transport  manager. The   rehabilitation measure  set by the Traffic Commissioner will have to be satisfied before that disqualification can be lifted.

Turfitt said: “If someone received an Acquired Rights certificate they should  have been continuously managing a transport operation for 10 years before  04  December  2009.  If  someone  has  obtained  an Acquired Rights certificate  in  error  or  fraudulently  they  can  expect  to  have  that certificate taken away.

“It  is important  for transport managers with acquired rights – and their operators – to check that they meet the necessary criteria.

“This case also demonstrates the responsibility transport managers have for the continuous and effective management of a transport operation. They are accountable for compliance standards and  should be available to assist examiners. It should not be left to drivers or other staff. The statutory duty is with the named transport manager. An operator’s transport manager should be present when enforcement authorities, especially the DVSA, come to inspect vehicle and driver records.

“Failing  to meet the most basic requirements of an operator’s licence is a cause of serious concern.  It is important for all operator licence holders –  including   those  in  industries where a vehicle may  be seen as consequential to the business – to recognise and support the commitments they have made when applying for a licence.

“These  are  the  basic  elements  of  compliance  and without them traffic commissioners will always have real concern about an operator’s future.”

Leave a comment for your chance to win £20 of John Lewis vouchers.

Every issue of Fleet News the editor picks his favourite comment from the past two weeks – get involved for your chance to appear in print and win!

Login to comment


No comments have been made yet.

Compare costs of your company cars

Looking to acquire new vehicles? Check how much they'll cost to run with our Car Running Cost calculator.

What is your BIK car tax liability?

The Fleet News car tax calculator lets you work out tax costs for both employer and employee