Fleet News

Support for road pricing to counter fuel tax losses, survey suggests

Hand on fuel pump

An alternative road tax system based on distance travelled to plug an anticipated loss in vehicle-related tax revenues is supported by half (53%) of motorists, research from Venson Automotive Solutions suggests.

More than one-in-five respondents (22%) favoured a nationwide road pricing ‘pay-as-drive’ scheme, with a further 31% saying they would support a ‘road miles’ system, for example, where the first 4,000 miles each year were free before paying a set cost per mile driven.

More than one third (38%) of respondents, meanwhile, preferred the introduction of a new electric vehicle (EV) tax, which could see drivers of heavier vehicles paying higher taxes. 

A worrying 27% of the 300 drivers surveyed, however, believed recouping the expected tax shortfall should fall on the shoulders of fleet operators.

Simon Staton, client management director of Venson Automotive Solutions, said: “Whilst it’s not anticipated that plans for a new EV tax will be revealed by the Chancellor in his October Budget, there is pressure on him to outline a 10-year trajectory to establish a financially viable means to achieving zero emissions in the UK.  

“Our survey findings confirm an understanding by the public that some sort of EV tax or related user charges will be necessary, which should offer Government assurances that people are mentally preparing to make the switch, if they haven’t done so already. 

“A favourable tax regime, together with a raft of new models and significant growth in the charging network, will play a vital part in accelerating our journey along the road to zero.”

With the sale of new internal combustion engine (ICE) cars and vans ending from 2030 and hybrids from 2035, and the Government consulting on a ban on new diesel trucks from 2040, the Treasury needs a plan to plug a potential £30 billion shortfall from road taxes, including fuel duty.

The Government is understood to be considering road pricing as a potential alternative, with vehicles charged per mile driven. However, when fleets were asked about the potential change to vehicle taxation earlier this year, opinion was divided.

Fewer than half (45%) of the respondents to the Fleet News survey said they were in favour of an alternative pay-as-you-go taxation scheme based on miles driven. More than a third (36%) said they were not.

MPs on the transport committee launched an inquiry into road pricing in December; it has yet to publish its findings.

Fleet & Mobility Live 2021

Fleet and Mobility Live 2022 register your interest


Fleet & Mobility Live is over for another year – and what an extra special couple of days we've had reconnecting the fleet and mobility sector at the NEC.

If you weren’t able to attend any of the seminar sessions, on-demand videos will be available soon so you can catch up in your own time. Stay tuned.

We would like to extend a huge thank you to our visitors, speakers, exhibitors, sponsors, supporting organisations, organisers and everyone else involved. We truly hope you had a great show.

Let us know your highlights from the last two days using the #FleetAndMobilityLive hashtag and tag us on Twitter and on LinkedIn.

See you next year - we're back on 11-12 October 2022.

 

Register your interest

Click here for fuel and fuel cards best practice and procurement insight

Leave a comment for your chance to win £20 of John Lewis vouchers.

Every issue of Fleet News the editor picks his favourite comment from the past two weeks – get involved for your chance to appear in print and win!

Login to comment

Comments

  • adamrollins - 21/09/2021 13:15

    Not sure where I stand with per mile road use charges. However, providing a free mileage allocation to drivers may seem like a way not to penalise low mileage drivers, but is it really fair? Currently low mileage users may pay he same RFL for their vehicle as any other driver of a similar vehicle, which may seem punative, but this is a small proportion of the overall taxation a driver pays to use the car. Obviously the larger part of the cost is the duty and VAT on fuel used. This is effectively a charge on a cost per mile basis. So why should this be changed in favour of the low mileage user? Business users may also want to think about how the free mileage allocation can be split between business and private mileage. Will it really be first x000 miles? Any driver with high business mileage will lose out on their free mileage allocation, making the cost for their personal mileage disproportionate. What if drivers keep changing company cars? Does the allocation go with the person or the car? What about pool cars? What about hire cars? What if the driver has a change of company? They may have used up their mileage allocation commuting to and driving for company A, which would mean that their business mileage at company B would be expensive.In any of these cases, how would free mileage then be applied?

  • GrandBob - 22/09/2021 14:55

    Yet again the aspect of cost per mile road charging rears its head. I do not understand why when the current RFL, duty and VAT on fuel are effectively charging per mile. I drive more miles, I buy more fuel, therefore I pay more tax. I buy a vehicle that does less miles per gallon, I use more fuel per mile and therefore pay more tax. Electric vehicles are no different in terms of the fuel aspect. The more miles you do, the more times you need to charge the batteries. The VAT that is paid on electricity is tax! Any cost per mile scheme will require a significant level of investment before the first penny can be collected. Agree with the various questions asked by adamrollins and would add to that foreign vehicles on UK roads and how they would be charged. If the government is serious about emissions, then use the existing tax regimes to encourage a move to electric vehicles.

Related content

Compare costs of your company cars

Looking to acquire new vehicles? Check how much they'll cost to run with our Car Running Cost calculator.

What is your BIK car tax liability?

The Fleet News car tax calculator lets you work out tax costs for both employer and employee