Fleet News

Should the EU ‘hit the pedal’ on mandatory speed-limiters?

Paul Brown, managing director of Cars on Demand

By Paul Brown, managing director of Cars on Demand

The latest hot topic being debated in the automotive industry, is the recent news that the European Parliament are making built-in speed limiters mandatory in all new cars built after 2022. Whilst many are against the idea, I must admit that I remain undecided.

I feel that it’s unlikely that those who are serial offenders, or who knowingly exceed the speed limit, will find a way to disable the limiter (or turn it off as it appears that it will have a manual override).

The chance of being caught speeding is already a risk they seem willing to take. What I do predict however, is that we will see a reduction in the number of drivers who ‘accidentally speed’, or pick up the pace when in a rush.

From a purely moral and logical point of view, it’s unreasonable to argue that the new devices aren’t a good idea; after all, it is illegal to break the speed limit.

In theory, the speed limiters are a safe way to reduce the number of accidents on the road caused by speeding, but as with any new technology, once put into practice I suspect there will be limitations that could potentially cause safety issues.

What we need to recognise and address is that speed alone is not dangerous, it is the inappropriate use of speed, lack of concentration and poor driving skills that are the main causes of accidents.

Driving at high speed is simply the added influence that determines the severity of the outcome.

My main concern is that drivers may rely too much on the new devices acting as a speed monitor, believing there is less of a need to focus on their surroundings and the journey ahead.

This creates a false sense of security, and as a consequence increases the chances of a serious accident happening.

Let’s put this into perspective. Consider a built-up area that has a speed limit of 30 mph, which the device recognises and sets the speed accordingly.

Add a group of 20 children playing by the roadside - will the device recognise that the limit isn’t appropriate for the current conditions? No, and if the driver isn’t concentrating it becomes a major issue.

Having driven a number of cars with automatic limiters that use GPS and sign recognition, I have experienced first-hand their inaccuracy in built up areas, as well as in roadworks, so sadly this isn’t just a theory.

Some may argue that most of these concerns are probably mitigated by the fact that the systems can currently be overridden, but what if that changes? Where will that leave us? I shall leave that thought with you.


Leave a comment for your chance to win £20 of John Lewis vouchers.

Every issue of Fleet News the editor picks his favourite comment from the past two weeks – get involved for your chance to appear in print and win!

Comment as guest


Login  /  Register

Comments

  • rosco7 - 15/04/2019 13:35

    It is highly unlikely that the EU will impose speed limiters for cars that cannot be overridden by the driver. The recent msm headline writers have not fully read the legislation, in that the EU wants speed limit detection which can prevent the driver from accidentally breaking the posted limit. They would not stop drivers from speeding. The EU put power restrictions on a vacuum cleaner that a household may use for two hours per week, but has never sought to limit the power of automobiles many of which could be used for over 4 hours per day. A fully implemented speed limiter for cars, would completely negate the purpose of many German car brands, as well as Jaguar. Especially in the run up to the CO2 reduction targets many of these will miss and levy hefty fines. As per the article, and my experience of the system in my own car. They are not ready for such adoption. They frequently pick up the speed limit of the junctions you pass, and miss signs that are faded or dirty. They are a useful additional protection from inadvertently missing a change in speed limit, but not much more than that. On Saturday morning, there was a serious GPS error in that accurate locations were not available (about 200m out), causing sat nav routing systems to fail. For these systems to work accurately, will need the Highways Authority here in the UK to spend a vast amount of money improving signage.

    Reply as guest

    Login  /  Register
  • Ross Baxter - 23/04/2019 08:43

    Interesting article Paul. It would be interesting to see how the limiters affect the car manufacturers, in that (in theory) no car will travel over 70 MPH on a British road; will that cause them to relegate engine power down their list of development priorities?

    Reply as guest

    Login  /  Register
  • Lynn Williamson - 04/10/2019 17:40

    I use my limiter all the time. However more especially after a prolonged speed limit for example 30 mph and at the end of it I select to increase the limit to the new one I have found on occasion that my right foot has increased pressure on the accelerator resulting in a momentary excessive increase in speed. This has happened when I have been in control of the speed limiter. Would my reaction have been as fast if the limiter was automatically increased by a sign?

    Reply as guest

    Login  /  Register