Fleet News

Citroen Xsara 1.9 TD SX estate - 9,850 miles

Citroen

Review

##citxsae.jpg --Right##THERE was a time when the search for a lower medium sector diesel estate car led straight to the doors of Citroen. In the old ZX estate the French manufacturer offered everything a fleet workhorse needs - large boot, low loading height and a fine diesel engine.

The same can be said of its successor, the Xsara estate, a smooth-lined car in which the boot looks part of the whole, rather than a bolt-on-box, but this car faces much tougher competition. Vauxhall's new 2.0-litre Di diesel engine is a revelation in the Astra estate, and the car itself is a quantum leap ahead of its predecessor.

The ungainly, but practical Peugeot 306 estate still offers one of the best turbodiesel engines around, while the new Ford Focus will offer a new turbodiesel engine to complement one of the best received driver's cars for years. Against this sort of competition the Xsara has its work cut out. It's not a bad car by any means, indeed it has many attributes to commend it, but these don't necessarily make it better than its rivals.

The Astra, for example, feels heavier in construction than the rather lightweight Xsara and boasts a better engine, while the Focus should handle better than the Citroen so long as Ford's estate version matches its hatchback's on-road performance.

This leaves the Xsara with few places to go other than competing on price, and here it scores strongly. At ú14,945 on-the-road for the 1.9 TD SX estate it's ú1,000 cheaper than the ú15,920 Astra 2.0 Di CD estate, ú1,300 cheaper than the ú16,320 Peugeot 306 GLX 1.9 TD and ú350 cheaper than the better-specified Focus Focus Ghia 1.8 Tdi estate.

Price differentials of this magnitude matter greatly in this budget-conscious, essential-user sector of the fleet market, and the Xsara's fuel economy (currently 43.5mpg) helps its running costs further. Drivers footing their own fuel bills will also enjoy this frugal consumption, although they may be disappointed at the relatively meagre specification for quite a high trim level - with ABS and a passenger airbag as options (although its is understood twin front and side airbags are to be introduced soon as standard) and air conditioning the only discernible luxury.

Overall, regardless of the Xsara's practicality, there's no ignoring the fierce competition it faces ahead, and its traditional values of being a competent all-round estate are now the bare minimum required to succeed in this fiercely-fought sector of the market, particularly with impressive new rivals from Ford and Vauxhall.

Jonathan Manning

CO2 emissions and fuel consumption data correct at time of writing. The latest figures are available in the Fleet News fuel cost calculator and the company car tax calculator.

Citroen C5 Aircross Hybrid long-term test | it's all about comfort

The new C5 Aircross hybrid marks the start of Citroen's move to have an electric option for every car and van in its range by 2025.

Our Fleet: Seat Leon ST 1.6 TDI Ecomotive - August 2014

The Leon ST was first unveiled at the 2013 Frankfurt motorshow, and it’s the first time an estate version has been offered in the Leon range.

Search Car Reviews