Fleet News

Best-selling cars fall into ‘depreciation trap’

A ‘DEPRECIATION trap’ affecting some of Britain’s most popular cars has been revealed by EurotaxGlass’s.

Five-door variants of some family hatchback models, such as the Vauxhall Astra, Citroën C4 and Renault Megane, suffer from significantly higher rates of depreciation than their three-door equivalents.

In the case of a Vauxhall Astra 1.6 Design, a five-door model bought last March (’06-plate) would have had an identical list price to the three-door version, yet just one year and 12,000 miles later the trade value of the five-door model is £1,250 less than the three-door.

However, some of the affected five-door cars have a list price up to £500 greater than their less practical three-door siblings. EurotaxGlass’s reports that a five-door Citroën C4 1.6 VTR Plus bought a year ago would have cost £400 more than the three-door model, but would now be worth £175 less.

Similarly, a five-door Renault Megane 1.6 VVT Dynamique bought in March 2006 would have cost £500 more than the three-door model with the same engine and specification, but after one year and 12,000 miles the five-door has a trade value just £25 greater than the three-door car.

‘These three cars have very clear visual differences between the three and five-door variants,’ said Jeff Paterson, senior car editor at EurotaxGlass’s.

‘The sportier appearance of the three-door models helps to give them broader appeal compared to their five-door siblings, in particular attracting style-conscious younger buyers who are less concerned about rear-seat accessibility. In the used car market the higher level of demand for three-door hatchbacks translates into stronger residual values.

‘With other cars in the C-segment, such as the Peugeot 307 and Volkswagen Golf, the visual differences between the three- and five-door models are more subtle and consequently the differential in residual values is less marked.’

Another factor influencing price differences between some three and five- door models is supply. ‘Five-door models are preferred by rental companies, responding to demand from their customers. This means that, when these cars are offered to the motor trade after six months, there is a significant imbalance of supply, depressing prices for five-door models.’

  • Comparison of retained values of three- and five-door family hatchbacks vehicle/cost new in April 2006: ‘06-plate / Glass’s trade value after 12 months and 12,000 miles / Retained value (% as proportion of cost new)

    Vauxhall Astra
    1.6 Design three-door / £14,862 / £9,550 / 64%
    1.6 Design five-door / £14,862 / £8,300 / 56%

    Citroën C4
    1.6 VTR Plus three-door / £13,907 / £8,425 / 61%
    1.6 VTR Plus five-door / £14,307 / £8,250 / 58%

    Renault Megane
    1.6 VVT Dynamique three-door / £13,087 / £7,375 / 56%
    1.6 VVT Dynamique five-door / £13,587 / £7,400 / 54%

    Peugeot 307
    1.6 S three-door / £12,512 / £7,450 / 60%
    1.6 S five-door / £13,112 / £7,875 / 60%

    Volkswagen Golf
    1.6 FSI S three-door / £13,707 / £10,425 / 76%
    1.6 FSI S five-door / £14,207 / £10,808 / 76%

  • Leave a comment for your chance to win £20 of John Lewis vouchers.

    Every issue of Fleet News the editor picks his favourite comment from the past two weeks – get involved for your chance to appear in print and win!

    Login to comment


    No comments have been made yet.

    Compare costs of your company cars

    Looking to acquire new vehicles? Check how much they'll cost to run with our Car Running Cost calculator.

    What is your BIK car tax liability?

    The Fleet News car tax calculator lets you work out tax costs for both employer and employee