Fleet News

Calls mount for a hands free ban

Calls are mounting for a ban on the use of hands-free phones while driving after new research revealed their use was detrimental to the performance of 97.5% of drivers.

Drivers on hands-free mobile phones took 20% longer to hit the brakes, following distances increased by 30% as drivers failed to keep pace with traffic and memory performance declined by 11%, according to the study by the University of Utah.

“It’s time that our politicians took note and put an end to the ridiculous situation where using a hand-held mobile is banned, but using hands-free isn’t,” said Ellen Booth, campaigns officer for road safety charity Brake.

“Using a hands-free phone isn’t safer than using a hand-held because it’s the conversation that’s the distraction.

“The person on the other end of the phone can’t tell when you are coming up to a junction or trying to manoeuvre so they will keep on talking and distracting you and expecting you to answer.”

The Department for Transport previously ruled out a review of the law in March 2009 when TRL research found that using a hands-free phone while driving was more likely to lengthen reaction times than having 80mg of alcohol in the bloodstream – the current UK limit – and no political party has shown the appetite to introduce a ban.

Kevin Clinton, head of road safety at the Royal Society for the Prevention of Accidents (RoSPA), said: “No phone call is worth a life. We urge employers to take the lead in making sure that staff switch off their phones when they switch on their engines.”

Katie Shepherd, from Brake, added: “Fleet managers should carefully consider measures they can take to eliminate, reduce and manage distractions specific to their type of operation.”

A Fleet News poll following the 2009 TRL research revealed a minority (45%) of fleets had banned their drivers from using hands-free phones.

3M banned its 4,000 employees from using hands-free mobiles while driving in July 2008. The ban covers all employees such as sales representatives whether they are driving company cars or using their own vehicles on business.

The company doesn’t marry call data with employees’ driving times in order to monitor compliance. Instead, the ban is based on winning hearts and minds with the repetition and reinforcement of messages over time.

3M’s managing director Doug Mitchell explained: “Our employees’ welfare and safety is paramount to 3M. We have an outstanding record when it comes to the prevention of workplace accidents and we are fully committed to keeping that record whether our employees are on 3M premises or on the move.”

Currently, drivers caught using a handheld mobile phone face three penalty points and a £60 fine, but even without a change in the law for hands-free phones drivers could face prosecution.

“The legislation seems to permit their use whilst driving, but the Crown Prosecution Service has prosecuted drivers for careless driving whilst using a hands-free phone,” explained David Faithful, consultant solicitor with Lyons Davidson.

“One notable prosecution in Warwickshire involving a company driver using a hands-free phone involved in a fatal accident was successfully prosecuted for careless driving but was acquitted of a more serious charge of causing death by dangerous driving.”

To read the research and for more information, click here

For more information about distraction guidelines, click here

Click here for safety and risk management best practice and procurement insight

Leave a comment for your chance to win £20 of John Lewis vouchers.

Every issue of Fleet News the editor picks his favourite comment from the past two weeks – get involved for your chance to appear in print and win!

Login to comment


  • Edward Handley - 20/04/2010 22:15

    The University of Utah used very similar research methods and techniques to the ones that TRL used several years ago, and no surprise, came to very similar conclusions. TRL proved hands free is a distraction and lowers driving performance to unacceptable levels. They also proved that using a hands free mobile while driving lowers a person's ability to think clearly and results in bad business decisions as well, yet many firms still expect their employees to deal with complex business matters while driving, and no doubt moan like hell when a decision proves to be a bad one. With the volume of traffic on the roads in this country, drivers need to be able to concentrate on the job in hand and any company that expects its drivers to use a hands free and deal with complex calls while driving is simply asking for trouble. Driving time with the phone turned off is seldom wasted - it often provides valuable time for busy people to think things over while doing something else and often results in better solutions and new ideas. If someone really is so important that they must deal with calls while on the road then it is probably worthwhile providing them with a driver. That way they can really concentrate on the business while providing valuable employment to someone who needs it!

Compare costs of your company cars

Looking to acquire new vehicles? Check how much they'll cost to run with our Car Running Cost calculator.

What is your BIK car tax liability?

The Fleet News car tax calculator lets you work out tax costs for both employer and employee