Fleet News

Warning over 'hidden' diesel running costs

Fleet operators could be in a for nasty financial shock if they fail to take account of the cost of replacing diesel exhaust fluid when calculating vehicle service, maintenance and repair budgets, according to Derwent Management Services (DMS).

Diesel exhaust fluid - which is best known to fleet operators as AdBlue, although that is a commercial trademark - is designed to treat exhaust gases and help vehicles meet stringent exhaust emissions standards.

First introduced into HGVs, a tank containing the fluid is now fitted in most light commercial vehicles and is increasingly to be found in cars.

However, automotive industry data provider DMS ssays not all car makers highlight the cost of topping up the diesel exhaust fluid tank or the cost of a ‘clean and drain’ in scheduled servicing costs.

Car and LCV diesel exhaust fluid tank capacities range between 18 and 31 litres and the fluid costs around £1.10 per litre. Typically a vehicle may need fluid levels topped up 50-100% at a service, although volume usage is linked to vehicle loading, environmental conditions and driving style with the smoother the style the longer the liquid will last.

Steve Chambers, DMS research director, said: "Topping-up the diesel exhaust fluid tank could cost at least £20 per company car or van per service once labour charges have been applied. But most motor manufacturers are not highlighting either the cost of the fluid, additional labour or the tank capacity in their published SMR calculations.

"In many cases, fleet managers only discover the additional cost when the vehicle has been serviced and it is highlighted on the related bill."

With the typical company car undergoing perhaps three services during its fleet life that could amount to, at a conservative estimate, £60 per vehicle having to be added to a fleet SMR’s budget.

Chambers added: "In many cases it is a hidden cost for fleet managers and therefore an unbudgeted one. On a 100-vehicle fleet with each model undergoing three services the additional SMR cost could amount to £6,000 and possibly more.

"Cost management is the number one issue facing all fleet decision-makers and we believe that manufacturers should clearly signpost the cost of diesel exhaust fluid in their SMR calculations."

Among motor manufacturers, Mr Chambers singled out Mercedes-Benz, which has introduced diesel exhaust fluid on its environmentally-friendly BlueTEC models, for clearly highlighting the cost of a top-up on a model’s first service and a ‘clean and drain’ on a second service and so forth on alternative services. The cost for a diesel exhaust fluid top up on the Mercedes ML 4x4 assuming a 50% top up is £23.80 including labour and £47.65 for a drain and refill.

He said: "Although only a small number of manufacturers are currently using diesel exhaust fluid to break down polluting nitrogen oxides into harmless water vapour and nitrogen gas we anticipate that a tank will increasingly become a standard feature on models."


Click here for fuel and fuel cards best practice and procurement insight

Leave a comment for your chance to win £20 of John Lewis vouchers.

Every issue of Fleet News the editor picks his favourite comment from the past two weeks – get involved for your chance to appear in print and win!

Login to comment

Comments

  • Bob - 04/01/2013 16:11

    This and other changes to meet the Euro6 targets will mean that diesel cars will become very expensive. People should now start looking at petrol cars. If you are doing 10k per year you should get a petrol. Also, fleets should look into their setup and include petrols if they are currently excluded. Look at Ford and their new 1.0T petrol engine, it's the way forward.

  • Thomas - 30/01/2013 09:27

    Filling up DEF at the dealer is definitely a rip-off. But you can do it yourself. It is not more compilcated that filling up washer fluid. Do you drive to the dealer for filling up washer fluid? I drive a VW Sharan Bluemotion. If it needs Adblue, I go to the pump at the truck petrol station and fill my 10 Liter bin at about 55 cent per Liter. A Liter of Adblue lasts for about 1000 kilometers, so the cost is rather neglible.

  • Edward handley - 05/10/2015 13:03

    Some rather selective figures here: Yes, you can easily pay £1.0 per litre for AdBlue, particularly if you buy 10 litre plastic cans at motorway service areas, but it is a lot cheaper when bought from the pump, or in a 1000 litre UBC which I am quite sure is what most garages will do once it becomes more common. Diesel is getting a lot of bad press at the moment, but the technology to seriously reduce emissions has been in use on many trucks since Euro 5, and is increasingly used of LCVs and cars. There are very few petrol engined vans around now, and I doubt we will see many users demanding petrol versions in the near future given the better mpg and low rev torque provided by a diesel, so the need now is to reduce emissions, not to propagate scare stories.

Compare costs of your company cars

Looking to acquire new vehicles? Check how much they'll cost to run with our Car Running Cost calculator.

What is your BIK car tax liability?

The Fleet News car tax calculator lets you work out tax costs for both employer and employee