Fleet News

Car parts swapper handed community service and £2,000 fine

A Widnes man was sentenced to 200 hours unpaid community service and ordered to pay more than £2,000 in compensation after stealing parts from a new hire car and replacing them with components from his much older vehicle.

Alexander Keating, 23, of Upton Lane, stole the gear shift knob, steering wheel, brake callipers and other parts from an Audi A3 loaned to him by accident management company, Accident Exchange and swapped them with parts from his ageing Audi S3.

Keating was caught when a garage worker at a local bodyshop spotted the mismatch of old parts on the A3. They reported the theft to local Police and Accident Exchange’s bespoke anti-fraud team, Asset Protection Unit (APU).

He pleaded guilty to the theft.

Sentencing Keating at Warrington Crown Court, Judge Nicholas Woodward described the case as “a serious example of theft” and demanded he pay over £2,500 in fines and court fees.

Keating, a bodyshop technician, stole the parts after his mother damaged her car in an accident and hired the Audi A3 from Accident Exchange.

He used the workshop of his employer – Blue Bell Bodyshop in Wilmslow – to carry out the parts swap, but lost his job after being caught.

Neil Thomas, director of Investigative Services at APU, said: “This guy is clearly no master criminal, to think that he could swap parts on one of our cars without us noticing.

“This case was another great example of good teamwork and how APU can work with businesses and local Police to bring all manner of motor fraudsters to justice.”

APU has helped to save £200,000 in fraudulent claims over the last 18 months.

Login to comment


  • Sarah - 28/03/2014 06:44

    I must be too honest, I would never have even thought to do this! Well done to the person who initially spotted something was wrong and reported it.

  • Alan W. - 01/04/2014 08:11

    It's been going on for years! I was in car & van hire for 38 years and regularly caught people swapping parts. One customer brought a Transit back with 2 tyres as smooth as a Formula One car-and denied that he had done it! You needed to be vigilant, there are some dodgy customers out there.

Compare costs of your company cars

Looking to acquire new vehicles? Check how much they'll cost to run with our Car Running Cost calculator.

What is your BIK car tax liability?

The Fleet News car tax calculator lets you work out tax costs for both employer and employee