Fleet News

Adult passengers are the biggest in-car distraction for drivers

Adult passengers are the biggest in-car distraction for drivers, a survey of 18,026 AA members reveals.

Nearly two out of five AA members (38% of the AA-Populus poll) say their attention has been significantly diverted by other people in the car, ‘old’ technology and ‘new’ technology in the past 12 months.

The survey, which asked - Have you been distracted, had a near miss or a crash caused by any of the following whilst driving over the past 12 months? - found that some of the more traditional distractions still pose the biggest threat.

The affected AA members responded:

Adult passengers – 18%
Twiddling with the radio – 16%
Children in the car – 14%
Operating the sat nav – 13%
Mobile phone conversation – 12%
Eating a sandwich – 9%
Drinking a coffee, water, etc – 7%
Texting – 5%
Emailing – 1%
Checking social media – 1%
Smoking – 1%

Overall, of the 6,867 respondents distracted, 548 (8%) had a near miss and 106 (1.5%) had a crash.

Latest Government statistics show that driver distraction contributed to 88 deaths in 2012, of which 17 were attributed to mobile phone use.

In-car distractions accounted for 5.5% of the 1,608 deaths in reported road accidents.

Killed and serious injuries from distractions made up 664 or 3% of the reported 21,796 total, while slight injuries from distraction numbered 4,848 or 3.5% of the 136,991 reported road accident casualties.

However, mobile phones, the only technology category in the ‘impairment or distraction’ set of statistics, showed a higher death rate compared to other in-car distractions.

The 17 deaths, set against a total of 548 casualties attributed to use of mobile phones, gives a fatality rate of 3%.

Among other in-car distractions, 71 of the 4,964 related accident casualties (1.4%) proved fatal.

The vast majority of the AA-Populus survey respondents (87%) accept that it is the driver's sole responsibility to ensure these new technology and ‘infotainment’ systems do not result in interaction and distraction whilst driving. These systems include mobile phone integration, sat-nav, voice control, access to music playlists on a mobile device, texting, e-mail or even web browsing systems in their vehicles.

“Although human distractions remain the biggest in-car threat, the figures for sat-navs and mobile phones give a warning for what might happen in the future as ‘infotainment’ and other technology become more commonplace,” said Edmund King, the AA’s president.

“The higher kill rate for mobile phone-related reported accidents provides a strong wake-up call.

“We are pleased to see the vast majority of AA members understand their responsibility when using this new kit, but that still leaves 6% who don’t.

“There will also be the temptation factor, which makes it all the more important that manufacturers add ‘smart’ features to in-car equipment, such as making it unavailable to drivers when the car is moving.

“That should also apply to retrofit equipment. It is important that the potential distraction of sophisticated in-car gadgets does not overtake the excellent progress towards safer cars with features such as Autonomous Emergency Braking or lane keeping assistance.

“In the sixties some people feared it would be dangerous to have radios in cars, in the eighties there were horror stories about sat navs and today there are potentially many more technology developments.

“We shouldn’t be Luddites about technological development but we must embrace technology whilst ensuring that the driver stays safely in control.

“The Transport Secretary has floated the idea of 6 penalty points for using a hand-held mobile. If this proposal was backed by an information and enforcement campaign, it could begin to change the daily dangers that the majority of our members see with drivers texting and tweeting at the wheel.”


Click here for safety and risk management best practice and procurement insight

Leave a comment for your chance to win £20 of John Lewis vouchers.

Every issue of Fleet News the editor picks his favourite comment from the past two weeks – get involved for your chance to appear in print and win!

Login to comment


No comments have been made yet.

Compare costs of your company cars

Looking to acquire new vehicles? Check how much they'll cost to run with our Car Running Cost calculator.

What is your BIK car tax liability?

The Fleet News car tax calculator lets you work out tax costs for both employer and employee