Fleet News

Pothole breakdowns ‘highest in more than a decade’, says RAC

The effects of a harsh winter have taken their toll on UK roads, with the RAC reporting that breakdowns caused by potholes in the first quarter of 2018 were the third highest recorded since 2006 when tracking of such faults started.

The percentage of RAC breakdowns likely to be attributed to damage caused by potholes and poor quality road surfaces, such as damaged shock absorbers, broken suspension springs or distorted wheels, doubled to 2.3% from 1.2% in the last quarter of 2017 – only the first quarters of 2015 (2.6%) and 2017 (2.7%) were higher.

This equated to 5,540 call-outs for these faults from a total of more than 244,000 RAC breakdowns over the same period – up from 2,841 in Q4 2017.

While the sheer volume of ‘pothole breakdowns’ may not have been as high as might have been expected considering the severity of the cold weather, the RAC expects the second quarter of the year to be a better indicator of the true state of the country’s roads.

It is, however, very concerning that the RAC’s most accurate picture of road quality – the RAC Pothole Index – has worsened slightly in Q1 2018. This is now the fourth successive quarter the index has worsened following a period of slow improvement.

Using a base of 1.00 established in 2006, the index for the first quarter of 2018 was 2.63, up from 2.59 the previous quarter – a year ago, however, in Q1 2017 it was 2.08.

The higher the figure, the greater the likelihood of suffering a breakdown caused by a pothole or other road surface defect and so, potentially, the worse the surface quality of the average road.

It should be pointed out that the index is still considerably lower than its peak which occurred in the first three months of 2010 at 3.5.

RAC chief engineer David Bizley said: “While RAC patrols saw the third highest quarterly share of pothole-related breakdowns in the first three months of 2018 the figure was not as high as we had been expecting, probably due the fact that the weather hit relatively late in the quarter. For this reason we feel we are likely to see more vehicles suffering pothole damage in the second quarter of 2018 compared with recent years.”

The start of the year normally sees the highest number of breakdowns attributable to poor quality road surfaces, but more telling will be how much this drops in the second quarter.

“Ever since we started analysing these faults, this second quarter figure has dropped sharply as local authorities catch up with repairs to address the worst damage to their roads caused by winter weather,” said Bizley.

“We will be monitoring the situation very closely to see what effect the harsh winter weather has had. If the index doesn’t reduce or, worse still, continues to increase then this will be a very strong indication that our roads are still in a dire state of repair.

“We know that many local authorities will be even more stretched in the new financial year and therefore having to deal with the effects of very poor weather in February and March will be a very unwelcome hit on their maintenance budgets for the next 12 months.”

The Government has made additional funding available through yet another emergency pothole fund, but Bizley believes that at best this will only allow councils to patch up roads that in many cases are in desperate need of longer term preventative maintenance.

He said: “Motorists understand that councils are under difficult financial pressures and are not able to spend as much on road maintenance as they have done in the past. The RAC has repeatedly called for a change of tack from the Government to give councils certainty of funding going forwards to address the huge backlog in maintenance over an agreed period.

“We are calling for ring-fencing of additional long-term funding to provide the money needed to bring our local roads back to a condition that is fit-for-purpose over a period of five to 10 years.”

For example, ring-fencing 3p for local road maintenance from the 58p fuel duty paid by motorists on every litre of fuel purchased over seven years would give councils raise an extra £9.5bn – enough, according to the recent survey of councils conducted by the Asphalt Industry Alliance, to eliminate the maintenance backlog on roads in England and Wales.

Bizley concluded: “Drivers contribute in excess of £40bn in motoring taxation a year and many feel they should not have to endure substandard roads as a result.” 

Click here for safety and risk management best practice and procurement insight

Login to comment


  • split rim - 18/04/2018 15:47

    Harsh winter?? Get a grip and don't fall for the standard local authority excuse, along with wet winter and freeze thaw conditions. The vast majority had a very mild winter with a couple of days at best of snow, which disappeared as fast as it arrived. Roads are in an unacceptable state because of historical underfunding, incredibly poor quality materials/workmanship and using sub-contractors, which the last time I checked none were registered charities and so are making a nice profit. Since when has it been necessary to report a pothole so a man from the council can assess it and mark it with paint before issuing a work order to a sub-contractor, who then drives past and probably over, hundreds of equally bad potholes to throw a couple of quid's worth of tarmac into a hole, returning again a few week's later ( and getting paid again one would assume) to "repair" the same hole again! It's a national disgrace.

Related content

Compare costs of your company cars

Looking to acquire new vehicles? Check how much they'll cost to run with our Car Running Cost calculator.

What is your BIK car tax liability?

The Fleet News car tax calculator lets you work out tax costs for both employer and employee