Fleet News

Millions of British motorists have brake problems

A new report from Kwik Fit suggests that Britain’s drivers are sharing the road with cars with defective brakes and are at risk of accidents as a result.

The new research shows that over five million motorists (15%) admit to having some sign of brake damage. 

Worryingly, a third of motorists with defective brakes, some 1.7 million drivers, have known about the problem for at least a month, without getting it repaired. 

Men are most likely to have neglected any issues – 24% of male motorists with a brake problem admitted to knowing about it for at least three months – compared to just 7% of women.

This neglect is all the more worrying when combined with drivers’ experiences.  Kwik Fit’s study also found that nearly one in five (18%) motorists have been in a car accident caused by braking errors. 

However, their responses might give a clue to their attitudes towards brakes - nearly three times as many people thought another driver’s braking was to blame for the accident, rather than their own (13% v 5%).

The symptoms of brake problems which 5.1 million drivers are experiencing include grinding noises when the brakes are applied, the car pulling to one side under braking, and the brake pedal feeling spongy. 

More than half a million drivers admit to having a brake warning light on the dashboard which they are ignoring.

When asked why they haven’t done anything about their braking issues, nearly one in ten (8%) admitted to simply not knowing what to do about it, a quarter (26%) were worried about the expense of getting it fixed, and one in six (17%) said they didn’t think anything was wrong.

In light of the Government’s new focus on improving the safety of young drivers, it is notable that more than one third (36%) of 18-24 year old drivers have symptoms of brake problems on their car.  This compares with just 3% for drivers over 65.

London drivers are most likely to be experiencing brake problems, with a quarter of them (24%) reporting symptoms. 

Motorists in Yorkshire can be the most relaxed about their fellow road users ability to stop – only 8% of drivers in Yorkshire and Humber say they have any brake problems.

Roger Griggs, communications director at Kwik Fit, says: “This research reveals that many of us have been in an accident where braking has been a cause, and yet far too many motorists admit they are driving around with defective brakes. 

“A grinding noise could be a result of pads which are worn and need replacing, pulling to one side could be a component sticking, and a spongy pedal could be due to air in the hydraulic system.

“It is vital that drivers are able to stop their car as quickly as possible in an emergency, and anyone suffering these symptoms may have their safety compromised as a result. 

“We would urge anyone experiencing these warning signs to get their brake system checked as soon as possible.”

Number of motorists with symptoms of brake problem



Number of motorists experiencing problem

Squealing from brakes

1.44 million

Excessive handbrake travel

1.24 million

Grinding noise from brakes

1.21 million

Car pulling to one side under braking

1.18 million

Spongy brake pedal

0.97 million

Brake warning light on

0.55 million

Continuous pulsating from pedal

0.45 million




Click here for service, maintenance & repair best practice and procurement insight

Leave a comment for your chance to win £20 of John Lewis vouchers.

Every issue of Fleet News the editor picks his favourite comment from the past two weeks – get involved for your chance to appear in print and win!

Login to comment


No comments have been made yet.

Compare costs of your company cars

Looking to acquire new vehicles? Check how much they'll cost to run with our Car Running Cost calculator.

What is your BIK car tax liability?

The Fleet News car tax calculator lets you work out tax costs for both employer and employee