Fleet News

Company drivers more careless according to survey

Drivers of company vehicles are 25% more likely than company drivers using their own vehicles to have a minor accident, according to a survey by IAM Drive & Survive on Springboard UK.

When asked about car park bumps and minor scrapes in a work vehicle versus a personal vehicle used for work, it was found that 63% of such accidents occurred in a work vehicle.

In addition, 17% admitted they were more likely to speed when driving for work, compared to 11% of people when driving for leisure purposes. Of the respondents only 31% said they didn't speed at all.

The survey also found that driving in a fuel-efficient manner was more of a consideration in private vehicles, 73%, compared to a work or company vehicle at 60%.

The survey also studied attitudes to vehicle maintenance in both company-owned and private vehicles. While between 54 and 61% of those surveyed regularly check essentials such as tyre pressures, windscreens and fluid levels when driving a personal vehicle, those same checks dropped to between 20 and 26% for those driving company vehicles.

Those who admitted to rarely or never checking their vehicle gave a variety of reasons for the lack of regular checks. These included a reliance on the vehicles' warning systems to alert them to problems, waiting for annual servicing to highlight issues, or that in some cases it just never occurred to them to check.

People driving for work are involved in an estimated third of all fatal and serious accidents. In addition to the human cost, poor driving also has a large impact on fleet operating costs, from increased fuel consumption and insurance premiums, to a reduced residual value of the company cars.

IAM Drive & Survive's chief executive Simon Best, said: "While many of those surveyed were careful drivers, we were concerned to find that just under a third recorded little or no concern for any damage to their company vehicle and that only a quarter of those using their vehicles for work consistently obeyed speed limits, compared to 39% in private cars.

"Our findings have highlighted a serious disconnect between the driver and their level of responsibility for the vehicle they drive.

"It seems that not owning the vehicle reduces the driver's desire to use it in the safest and most fuel-efficient manner, as well as distancing them from the responsibility of checking their vehicle is roadworthy.

"The benefits of car ownership aren't purely financial. People are a company's biggest asset, and providing them with the necessary skills to be safe on the road is essential."

Click here for safety and risk management best practice and procurement insight

Leave a comment for your chance to win £20 of John Lewis vouchers.

Every issue of Fleet News the editor picks his favourite comment from the past two weeks – get involved for your chance to appear in print and win!

Login to comment


No comments have been made yet.

Compare costs of your company cars

Looking to acquire new vehicles? Check how much they'll cost to run with our Car Running Cost calculator.

What is your BIK car tax liability?

The Fleet News car tax calculator lets you work out tax costs for both employer and employee