Fleet News

Overclaiming on business expenses could cost UK economy £1.6bn a year

A red car with money coming through its sunroof

Professionals who overclaim on their business expenses could be costing the UK economy £1.6 billion a year, according to a new report by Allstar Business Solutions.

The study, which questioned 1,000 working professionals, revealed that 36% of drivers have overclaimed mileage and 17% of employees deliberately overclaim on all of their business expenses each month, while a further 41% felt there wasn’t anything wrong with doing so, despite it being illegal.

With more than half of respondents (55%) admitting to adding up to 10% on to their expenses every month, and a quarter of people claiming up to 20% extra, this is estimated to be costing the UK economy £1.6bn each year.

When asked why they choose to overclaim, 40% of respondents said they don’t feel they get paid enough and  36% said they do so to make up for money owed from lost receipts. Almost a third (29%) simply follow their colleagues lead, stating that it’s something that “everyone does”, while 28% simply feel they can “get away with it”.

Paul Baker, vice president customer management at Allstar Business Solutions, said: “It is of no doubt that our research has revealed some shocking findings and it appears overclaiming is a very big problem for British businesses. Not only is it costing individual companies, it is also having a much bigger impact on our wider economy as a whole and people don’t seem to care that it is both dishonest and illegal.

"To help businesses we have created a dedicated white paper looking at pay and reclaim in much more detail, specifically in relation to fuel which is commonly one of the biggest expenses for a company. We hope that this will encourage business owners to review processes they have in place in order to minimise these losses.”

It seems men are less bothered in general about expenses as the study found that males (20%) are more likely to overclaim on expenses than women (15%), and more female professionals felt that it is wrong to claim more than they’re owed (63%). Those in Northern Ireland (24%), the Midlands (23%) and the North West (30%) are most likely to overclaim.

With almost three quarters (73%) of employees spending up to £100 on business expenses every month, the most unusual items professionals admitted to reclaiming were: flowers, alcohol for personal use, haircuts, home improvements, personal groceries, personal parking fines, meals which weren’t business related, hotel breaks with the family.

The survey also found a difference in attitude among different age groups with a third of 18-34 year olds saying they’ve overclaimed in the last 12 months but only 15% of over 55s admitting to have done so recently.

The business sectors most likely to overclaim on expenses include: creative arts (50%), energy and utilities (46%), information, research and analysis (40%), ernvironment and agriculture (36%), and business, consulting and management (29%).

Baker added: “We also found that 80% spend between one–two hours a month working on their expenses claims each month. Those hours spent processing could be better spent working on more productive tasks.”

Click here for fuel and fuel cards best practice and procurement insight

Leave a comment for your chance to win £20 of John Lewis vouchers.

Every issue of Fleet News the editor picks his favourite comment from the past two weeks – get involved for your chance to appear in print and win!

Login to comment


  • Tim - 22/02/2017 15:29

    Curious to know how it costs the UK economy £1.6bn a year if the money is ultimately ending up in individuals' pockets rather than business' bank accounts.

Compare costs of your company cars

Looking to acquire new vehicles? Check how much they'll cost to run with our Car Running Cost calculator.

What is your BIK car tax liability?

The Fleet News car tax calculator lets you work out tax costs for both employer and employee