Fleet News

Government review may lead to ‘radical changes in travel and subsistence payments’

A proposal to abolish tax allowances on travel and subsistence expenses could be revived by the Government’s current consultation into expenses tax reliefs believes Alphabet.

Clive Buhagiar, head of pricing and planning at Alphabet, says that the proposal by the Office of Tax Simplification (OTS) is still on the table.

“In 2014, the OTS recommended a formal, comprehensive study on what it called ‘the possible radical idea’ of travel and subsistence expenses being allowable only if reimbursed by the employer,” said Buhagiar.

“From HMRC’s perspective, this would eliminate a huge number of claims for tax relief on expense costs that either weren’t reimbursed by employers or which were reimbursed at less than the relevant AFR or AMAP rate.”

The current review of expenses tax reliefs, which runs until June 12, is partly designed to help HM Treasury understand why tax relief claims rose by 25% to £800 million per year between 2010 and 2015.

“The ongoing confusion around the implications of the Finance Bill is driving many businesses to consider offering cash alternatives to company cars, which would only further exacerbate the expenses issue highlighted by the Government,” said Buhagiar. “Changes resulting from the consultation could have major impacts on fleet, travel and subsistence policies, especially if the OTS’s recommendation is taken up.”

From a fleet perspective, all drivers would then want to be reimbursed for fuel and mileage at the full-scale rates since they could no longer claim tax relief if paid less. It would also entail more administration for businesses because employees would take care to put every scrap of travel costs through the expenses process, knowing that they would not be able to claim tax relief on non-reimbursed costs at the end of the tax year.

Buhagiar continued: “Fortunately, new technologies and working practices are already coming into play in this area. Mobility solutions, such as corporate car sharing and flexible rental offer the prospect of near-seamless alternatives to pool cars, taxis and public transport with little or no need for employees to reach into their own pockets for travel.”

Alphabet is urging fleets to make their voice heard by responding to the consultation. Buhagiar also recommends that fleet decision makers review the OTS’s 2014 report on employee expenses and benefits (available by clicking here) before making submissions.

Further recommendations by the OTS include lifting the requirement for employers to retain receipts for scale charge expense claims, and that tax reliefs for travel and subsistence should be reviewed formally every 10 years to make sure the system keeps up with changing work patterns.

“While the current Treasury consultation deals with the last of these recommendations, the document makes no specific mention of waiving the requirement for receipts or of making radical changes to travel and subsistence allowances,” he said. “However, it does encourage respondents to feel free to submit broad evidence and fresh ideas, so businesses may like to address issues raised by the OTS in their submissions.”

The current consultation questionnaire can be found on the Gov.uk website by clicking here.

The Government seeks views from anyone with an interest in employee expenses, particularly employers and employees who use the tax relief across all sectors and employer size, as well as tax professionals and advisors.

Respondents should feel free to provide broad evidence or answer specific questions. The government is particularly interested in quantitative data where possible.

The deadline for responses to the call for evidence is June 12, 2017.

Login to comment


No comments have been made yet.

Compare costs of your company cars

Looking to acquire new vehicles? Check how much they'll cost to run with our Car Running Cost calculator.

What is your BIK car tax liability?

The Fleet News car tax calculator lets you work out tax costs for both employer and employee