Fleet News

Nissan Qashqai long-term test | new petrol engine suits all but highest mileage users

7
Nissan
BIK List Price
£24,575
Nissan Qashqai BIK list price
BIK Percentage
30%
Nissan Qashqai BIK Percent
CO2
130g/km
Nissan Qashqai CO2
Combined MPG
41.4 (WLTP)
Nissan Qashqai MPG

Review

The Qashqai’s new 1.3-litre petrol engine, which replaced the 1.2-litre and 1.6-litre units last October and was developed in collaboration with Daimler, is proving popular with fleets.

As well as the 140PS manual we’re testing, it’s available as a 160PS six-speed manual or a 160PS seven-speed DCT.

Year-to-date fleet sales of the Qashqai are in the diesel’s favour (14,059 versus 13,765, as at September) but it’s a different story looking at September alone.

That month, there were 4,973 fleet registrations of the Qashqai and the majority were petrol (3,453 compared with 1,520).

A year ago, just prior to the new petrol engine’s launch, it was the diesel which was more popular (2,123 fleet sales versus 1,911).

But is petrol really the best choice for company car drivers and fleet managers?

Pitting our 140PS version against the 115PS 1.5-litre diesel, using the company car tax calculator on the Fleet News website, over four years and 80,000 miles brings up some interesting numbers.

The employee is better off from a tax perspective in the petrol. It costs a 20% taxpayer in England £1,463, while the diesel costs £96 more (£1,559).

For a 40% taxpayer, the saving in the petrol is £192 (£2,925 versus £3,117).

The employer saves £66 in Class 1A National Insurance with the petrol (£1,009 versus £1,075).

For depreciation, the petrol again has the edge (21.19p per mile compared with 23.19ppm).

Service, maintenance and repair (SMR) costs are also a fraction lower in the petrol (3.76ppm versus 3.85ppm).

However, there is, unsurprisingly, a greater difference in the diesel’s favour for fuel costs. It costs 2.66ppm (£2,128 over 80,000 miles) more to be in the petrol rather than the diesel.

That makes the diesel the best option for overall running costs with a total cost of £30,712 over four years and 80,000 miles compared with £31,165 in the petrol.

This highlights the importance of considering how many miles a company car driver does to determine the best option.

I’ve clocked up only about 2,000 miles since taking delivery of the Qashqai in June, making the petrol engine a better choice for me than the 1.5-litre or 1.7-litre diesel units.


Sat-nav reliable despite annoying warnings - September 2019

“Caution! Road with restricted access.” That warning has been coming out of the Qashqai’s speakers far too frequently. It has been telling me each time I turn into my estate or enter the office car park or shop at a certain supermarket.

At first, there was no apparent way to silence it – even with the sat-nav and infotainment system turned off. But, thankfully, I have now found an option buried in the guidance settings which does the trick.

The sat-nav is otherwise reliable and its predicted times of arrival has proved spot on thanks to TomTom Premium Traffic, which is a feature of the new NissanConnect system.

Despite the upgraded system, the interface looks dated, especially compared with rival models from the Volkswagen Group.

On a positive note, Apple CarPlay and Android Auto are now included (Acenta grade and above) and there is a wealth of other standard technology on our N-Connecta model.

It includes two safety packs: safety shield plus (Acenta grade and above), which gives intelligent driver alert (detects driver fatigue), blind spot warning, rear cross traffic alert and moving object detection; and smart vision (N-Connecta grade and above), which includes anti-dazzle rear view mirror, traffic sign recognition, high beam assist, lane departure warning, intelligent emergency braking with pedestrian recognition and front and rear parking sensors.

The 360-degree camera and intelligent park assist (automated parking) are separate features.


How do the Qashqai's wholelife costs stack up? - August 2019

The Nissan Qashqai is one of the most popular SUVs, but it faces fierce competition from a host of rivals when looking at wholelife costs.

Comparing our 1.3-litre petrol Qashqai N-Connecta (P11D of £24,375) with the 1.0 TSi Škoda Karoq SE Technology (P11D of £21,720), the 1.2 T Vauxhall Grandland X Business Edition (P11D of £23,690) and the 1.5 TSi Volkswagen Tiguan Match (P11D of £27,105) over four years and 80,000 miles, the Qashqai is the second most expensive for benefit-in-kind (BIK) tax. It costs the 20% taxpayer in England £1,463 per year, £184 more than the Grandland X (£1,279) and £247 more than the Karoq (£1,216). However, the Tiguan is the most expensive at £1,626.

For the employer, the Karoq has the lowest Class 1A NIC (£839), £170 less than the Qashqai (£1,009). However, the Qashqai is £113 cheaper than the Tiguan (£1,122). The Grandland X is the closest to the Karoq (£883).

There is one area where the Qashqai comes out top – SMR. It costs 3.76p per mile compared with the Karoq’s 3.90ppm, Tiguan’s 4.30ppm and Grandland X’s 4.64ppm.

Overall, the Karoq is the cheapest to run at 34.37ppm; the Grandland X is 38.02ppm, the Qashqai 39.35ppm and Tiguan 41.54ppm.

For fuel, it’s the Grandland X which has the highest combined mpg on paper (44.8) meaning a ppm figure of 12.99 while the Karoq is next best with 13.38 (43.5mpg), followed by the Qashqai (14.06ppm and 41.4mpg) and the Tiguan (14.23ppm and 40.9mpg).

The Karoq holds its value the best (37%), followed by the Tiguan (32%), Grandland X (31%) and Qashqai (29%). However, per mile, the Tiguan costs the most in terms of depreciation (23.01p), followed by the Qashqai (21.53p), the Grandland X (20.39p) and the Karoq (17.09p).

So, on paper, the Karoq is the best bet. But what is it like to live with? Read our long-term review.


We welcome a Nissan Qashqai 1.3 DIG-T N Connecta to our fleet - July 2019

This is my second stint in a Nissan Qashqai. The first was back in 2008 when I joined the Fleet News editorial team. The Qashqai had launched the year before and it was an interesting car to have on long-term test as there was nothing else quite like it – it was the car that spawned the crossover sector.  

Some road testers at the time were critical as they felt it wasn’t an MPV and it wasn’t quite an SUV and therefore it ‘didn’t know what it was’. But the judges of the Fleet News Awards were impressed with its distinctiveness, running costs and technology, and voted it the best small family car that year.

Today, the Qashqai is firmly established as one of the best selling cars in the UK (with total year to date sales of 29,180 in June, two-thirds of which were true fleet).

But because so many are sold now and there are so many other crossover/compact SUV cars on the market the Qashqai has lost its distinctiveness. In fact, I’d go so far as to say that the latest version we’re testing (which was facelifted in 2017) is ‘run of the mill’. 

What’s most interesting now is not its looks but what’s under the bonnet – a 1.3-litre petrol engine which has been developed under the Renault-Nissan Alliance and Daimler partnership and became available on the Qashqai last year. 

Its CO2 emissions are 121g/km while the official combined mpg is 53.2. Our test car is averaging 40.3mpg, with the best figure to date 48.8.

Back in 2008, it was the 1.5-litre diesel I tested and the fact we’re now in a petrol is another sign of how things have moved on in the market. 

Top Speed
120mph
Nissan Qashqai Top Speed
VED band
G
Nissan Qashqai Ved
Fuel Type
Petrol
Nissan Qashqai Fuel Type
Residual Value
3 Year 60k : £9,300
4 Year 80k : £7,225
Running Cost (ppm)
3 Year 60k : 42.44
4 Year 80k : 39.16

CO2 emissions and fuel consumption data correct at time of writing. The latest figures are available in the Fleet News fuel cost calculator and the company car tax calculator.

Nissan Juke first drive | tamer looks and improved interior boost fleet appeal

New Juke looks less radical than the outgoing model but is likely to be every bit as divisive as before.

Toyota C-HR looks familiar but packs more punch | first drive

‘If it isn’t broken, don’t fix it’ approach means the facelifted C-HR offers few surprises

Search Car Reviews



Leave a comment for your chance to win £20 of John Lewis vouchers.

Every issue of Fleet News the editor picks his favourite comment from the past two weeks – get involved for your chance to appear in print and win!

Comment as guest


Login  /  Register

Comments

No comments have been made yet.