Fleet News

FN50 2017 car reliability survey - BMW 3 Series most reliable car for 8th year in a row

Top 10 most reliable cars operated by FN50 2017 contract hire companies

FN50 2017 most reliable car - BMW 3 Series

BMW has yet again retained its position at the top of the FN50 car reliability survey, with the 3 Series keeping its crown as the most reliable car on contract hire for the eighth consecutive year. 

It achieved the top position in a reliability index of 700,000 cars operated by FN50 companies.

The German brand has also completed a hat-trick in taking the title as best manufacturer, a victory it also celebrated in 2016 and 2015.

An all-new 3 Series is due next year, but the current model has been an overarching success since its launch in 2011. 

Last year a plug-in hybrid powertrain was added to the line-up, badged 330e.

Retaining second place in the reliability index is the Volkswagen Golf, which received a facelift and new petrol engines earlier this year. It also offers a choice of fully-electric and plug-in hybrid options.

The Audi A3 made a surprise return to third place, having held fourth for the past two years. It bumped the recently re-launched A4 to ninth – a disappointing drop for the new model.

Honda now occupies fourth place with the Civic, continuing as the only Japanese model in the top-five. Having undergone a total redesign, the new Civic was launched in the spring with a choice of two turbo-charged petrol engines. A diesel is expected early next year.

Another model that debuted this year was the all-new BMW 5 Series. The car has jumped from sixth position to fifth; making BMW the only manufacturer with two models in the top five.

Volkswagen’s second appearance in the rankings comes in sixth position, with the Passat. It’s a jump of one place and its in-house rival, the Škoda Octavia, is close behind occupying seventh – an improvement of three places since last year.

Taking eighth position is the Nissan Qashqai, a car which jumped to the top of the UK sales charts in September following a minor facelift. Early next year, the model will offer a semi-autonomous driving system, but remains a firm fleet favourite thanks to its low 99g/km CO2 emissions. 

Mercedes-Benz has snuck into the top 10 with the E-Class this year, a strong performance for the newly launched model. But the ageing C-Class – which held eighth last-year – has dropped to 14th in this survey. A new C-Class is expected next year.FN50 2017 most reliable car quote

Interestingly the entire top 10 is made up of either German- (80%) or Japanese-owned brands (20%), although both the Qashqai and Civic are built in Britain.

Eleventh place is held by the Spanish-built Ford Fiesta, which is the UK’s best-selling car overall, while Japanese brand Toyota has managed to retain two models in the top 15 with the Prius occupying 12th and the Auris in 15th. Thirteenth place is held by the Vauxhall Astra.

The manufacturer rankings have seen little movement at the top. Audi, Mercedes-Benz and Volkswagen have all retained their positions under BMW, as in the 2016 survey.

Ford has made the biggest jump this year, placing it fifth – having ranked ninth last year.

The tables have turned for the Japanese manufacturers this year. Honda has climbed the table to rank sixth while Toyota has slipped past Nissan to rank eighth. In contrast, last year Toyota comfortably led the pack under the Germans – holding fifth place in 2015 and 2016.

Vauxhall has managed to climb into the top 10 this year, holding ninth place overall, as has Škoda which is now the gatekeeper to the top 10.

Korean brands have performed less impressively this year. Hyundai managed to creep up one place to 11th, but Kia dropped out of the top 15 altogether, having held 15th last year.

British brands have delivered a stronger performance though. Mini takes 12th place while Jaguar takes 13th, pushing Japanese-rival Lexus out of the top 15 and outranking its stablemate Land Rover – which sits in 15th.

Mitsubishi, manufacturer of the highly-popular Outlander PHEV, has hung on to its place in 14th for the second year in a row.

Best performing cars (2016 in brackets)
1 (1) BMW 3 Series (330E SE test drive)
2 (2) VW Golf (VW Golf 2017 facelist test drive)
3 (4) Audi A3 (1.6 TDI Sportback S-tronic test drive)
4 (5) Honda Civic (Civic 1.0 VTEC Turbo test drive)
5 (6) BMW 5 Series (5 Series first drive)
6 (7) VW Passat (Passat first drive)
7 (10) Skoda Octavia (Octavia estate first drive)
8 (9) Nissan Qashqai (Qashqai facelift first drive)
9 (3) Audi A4
10 (-) Mercedes-Benz E-Class (E350e first drive)


Best performing manufacturers (2016 in brackets)
1 (1) BMW
2 (2) Audi
3 (3) Mercedes-Benz
4 (4) VW
5 (9) Ford
6 (8) Honda
7 (6) Nissan
8 (5) Toyota
9 (-) Vauxhall
10 (7) Skoda



> Car running costs

> Fuel cost calculator

> Company car tax calculator

> Car CO2 and fuel economy figures (including 'real world' test figures)

> Current BIK tax bands

Leave a comment for your chance to win £20 of John Lewis vouchers.

Every issue of Fleet News the editor picks his favourite comment from the past two weeks – get involved for your chance to appear in print and win!

Login to comment


  • George Asda - 10/11/2017 16:25

    quite incredible really as in wider commissioned reviews, BMW come extremely low. Alfa romeo has come out far higher in all recent surveys - why do brands that people really want to own and drive not even feature in FN awards. Stelvio and Giulia by alfa are in my view the most stunning cars to hit the road in years - and backed with strong RVs and quality

Related content

Compare costs of your company cars

Looking to acquire new vehicles? Check how much they'll cost to run with our Car Running Cost calculator.

What is your BIK car tax liability?

The Fleet News car tax calculator lets you work out tax costs for both employer and employee